In product management, metrics are meant to guide decisions, not decorate presentations. Yet all too often, teams rely on surface-level indicators that look good in dashboards but fail to tell the true story of product impact. These are vanity metrics—numbers that rise without meaning, charts that move without consequence.
To build truly valuable products, we need to shift our mindset: from measuring what’s easy to measuring what matters. This article explores how product teams can move beyond vanity metrics to adopt value-driven indicators that shape strategy, inform trade-offs, and drive outcomes.
What Are Vanity Metrics?
Vanity metrics are data points that seem impressive but lack actionable context. They include things like:
- Total signups
- Pageviews
- App downloads
- Number of features shipped
While these may indicate motion, they rarely reflect whether we’re solving real problems or delivering sustainable value. They can be manipulated, misinterpreted, or worse—incentivize the wrong behaviors.
The Risk of Measuring the Wrong Thing
When teams prioritize vanity metrics:
- Success becomes about growth over retention
- Features are released for optics, not outcomes
- Short-term wins mask long-term problems
- Teams feel pressure to “move the needle” without clarity on which needle matters
Metrics should be a compass, not a scoreboard. They should guide decisions, not justify them after the fact.
Toward Value-Driven Metrics
Real product metrics help teams:
- Understand user behavior and needs
- Track impact over time
- Align decisions with outcomes
- Prioritize based on value, not volume
These metrics tend to fall into three categories:
- Outcome Metrics
- Reflect progress toward strategic goals
- Examples: retention rate, task success rate, customer satisfaction (CSAT), NPS
- Behavioral Metrics
- Show how users interact with your product
- Examples: feature adoption, time to value, completion rate, frequency of use
- Leading Indicators
- Predict future performance or outcomes
- Examples: activation rate, onboarding completion, trial-to-paid conversion
How to Choose Metrics That Matter
- Tie Metrics to User and Business Value If a metric doesn’t connect to a real user need or a strategic business goal, question its relevance.
- Use a Mix of Quantitative and Qualitative Signals Numbers tell you what is happening. Stories tell you why. Use both.
- Avoid Metric Overload Too many metrics create noise. Focus on a small, meaningful set that aligns with your current goals.
- Align Metrics Across Teams Shared metrics drive shared accountability. Ensure product, design, and engineering are measuring success the same way.
- Revisit and Refine Regularly As your product evolves, so should your metrics. Review them at regular intervals to ensure continued relevance.
Conclusion
Metrics are powerful when used wisely. They can drive focus, reveal insight, and validate direction. But when chosen poorly, they can lead even the best teams astray.
As product leaders, we must ask not just “what are we measuring?” but also:
- Why does this metric matter?
- What decision will it inform?
- What behavior does it encourage?
The goal isn’t just to move numbers—it’s to move people, products, and businesses forward with purpose.
The portfolio mindset 
Leave a comment